Internet Trolls: A Guide to the Different Flavours

It’s relatively easy to deal with those who pour forth hatred online. But the greater threat comes from the more subtle spreaders of misery and doubt.

In 2010, I had published my first research paper on Internet trolling: “Tough on data misuse, tough on the causes of data misuse: A review of New Labour’s approach to information security and regulating the misuse of digital information (1997–2010).” Over the years, countless high-profile trolling incidents have demonstrated that trolling is far more pervasive than it first appeared.

Most people have a basic understanding of trolling as causing mischief online for amusement. However, fewer realise that trolling encompasses a wide range of behaviours. My research at Crocels Research identified several categories: Haters, who disrupt websites with offensive content; Bzzzters, who talk endlessly and spread misinformation; Lolcows, who make fools of themsleves, and Eyeballers, who wait for the opportune moment to cause disruption.

Interestingly, trolls who engage in overt, abusive behaviour are often the easiest to address. Their motivations are typically transparent—they aim to provoke emotional distress or manipulate behaviour, such as pressuring someone to delete their social media accounts. These overt actions are relatively straightforward to identify, block, and, when warranted, prosecute.

The greater challenge lies in addressing covert trolls. These individuals operate in a more ambiguous domain, neither overtly offensive nor openly hateful. Instead, they sow doubt and discontent with subtlety. A covert troll’s intent is often obscured, and they may present themselves as credible or reasonable, making it difficult to justify blocking or silencing them. When confronted, they may invoke arguments about free speech or accuse their targets of censorship, leaving victims conflicted between upholding principles of open dialogue and safeguarding their mental well-being.

These covert trolls represent a more insidious threat. Their behaviours, though damaging, often evade existing legal frameworks. Some argue they should remain outside legal purview to protect free speech, but for the ordinary user, their impact can be profound, fostering uncertainty, stress, and disillusionment.

The question I am most frequently asked is: “How should I deal with trolls?” My ongoing research aims to identify effective response strategies for ordinary users, evaluating the risks and benefits of each. However, before practical solutions can be fully realised, a broader cultural shift is needed.

One of the most disheartening findings of my work at Crocels Research is the pervasive dismissal of online misbehaviour as insignificant. Trolling, cyberbullying, and related phenomena are often trivialised with phrases like, “It’s just the internet” or “You can always log off.” This attitude mirrors outdated victim-blaming mentalities in offline contexts and hampers meaningful progress.

Online harm encompasses a spectrum, from predatory behaviours like cyberstalking and online grooming to deceptive acts like catfishing and e-hoaxing. Yet, these actions are frequently seen as less real or impactful than their offline counterparts.

To address these issues, we need robust research initiatives like those spearheaded by Crocels Research, which investigates the complexities of online behaviour and develops strategies for mitigating harm. But more fundamentally, a societal shift is essential. We must abandon the notion that the internet is “real” only when it serves our interests and “unreal” when it challenges us.

The internet is one of the most transformative technologies of our era. Its vast potential for good is matched by its capacity for harm. Recognising and addressing the latter is not optional; it is imperative if we are to fully realise its promise.

Social tagging: > > > >

Leave a Reply